Non-compliant product is not the same as dangerous product
A non-compliant product is not necessarily a dangerous product. It seems obvious, but it remains one of the most common confusions in product safety.
It happens often: a product is found to violate a standard or legal requirement, and almost automatically, it is concluded that it is dangerous and must be withdrawn from the market. This is not the case.
In product safety, it’s important to distinguish between two related issues that are not the same: compliance with legislation and the level of risk of the product.
What is non-compliance
A product can violate regulations for many reasons. For example:
- Missing mandatory information.
- The labeling is incorrect.
- The identification of the manufacturer or importer is not present.
- The technical documentation is incomplete.
- A warning is not correctly worded.
- The product does not meet a specific requirement of a technical standard.
All these cases can constitute non-compliance and require a corrective action. But from this alone, one cannot automatically deduce that there is a serious risk to the consumer.
What is risk: the question to ask
To determine if a product is dangerous, one must pose a different question:
What harm can the product cause, to whom, under what circumstances, and with what probability?
Here we enter into risk assessment. It is not enough to identify the violation: one must construct a reasonably foreseeable accident scenario, determine the possible severity of the injury, and estimate the probability that it will occur. It is the same approach followed by the risk assessment methodology used in the European Safety Gate system.
Therefore, two products with the same technical non-compliance can present completely different levels of risk.
| Non-conformity | Risk | |
|---|---|---|
| Key question | What requirement does the product fail to meet? | What harm can it cause, to whom, and with what probability? |
| How it is determined | By comparing the product with applicable legislation and standards | By conducting a risk assessment based on accident scenarios |
| What it tells us | What is wrong | How important it is from a safety perspective |
A ‘FAIL’ test does not automatically mean ‘dangerous product’
This is another common mistake. A laboratory may indicate that a product does not meet a specific requirement of a standard. That result is very important, but it still raises the question: what risk does that non-compliance actually generate?
It could be a documentation deficiency, a technical deviation with little practical impact, or conversely, a defect capable of causing electrocution, fire, strangulation, asphyxiation, or other serious injury.
In other words: the test result identifies the problem; the risk assessment determines its importance from a safety perspective.
And conversely: complying with a standard does not guarantee that the product is safe.
The opposite can also occur. Just because a product meets a standard doesn’t mean it is safe under all circumstances.
There may exist a risk that the standard has not adequately contemplated, a reasonably foreseeable use different from the originally intended one, or a combination of characteristics that creates a new danger.
Conformity with a standard is very important evidence, but the ultimate obligation remains the same: that the product is safe, as required by Regulation (EU) 2023/988 concerning the general safety of products (GPSR).
Why it is important to make this distinction
Because corrective measures must be proportionate to the problem and the existing risk. Not all non-conformities justify retrieving the product from consumers. Depending on the case, it may be sufficient to:
- Correct the documentation.
- Modify the labeling.
- Temporarily halt distribution.
- Correct the units that will be manufactured going forward.
- Withdraw certain batches.
And, when the risk is significant enough, carry out a product recall.
Conclusion: two questions that should not be mixed
When a safety problem arises, it is advisable to always separate two questions, in this order:
- What requirement does the product fail to meet?
- What risk does that non-compliance really pose?
Confusing them can lead to two equally serious errors: overreacting to a minor non-conformity or underestimating a defect that could indeed cause significant harm.
In product safety, non-compliance tells us what is wrong. Risk assessment helps us decide what we should do about it.
Leave a Reply